“It was only a pet.” Why does it hurt so much?

by Romina Rubino

Grieving the loss of a pet, and finding room for what we have lost.

The first time you come home, you already know.

Yet part of you is still waiting. For a sound, a movement, that familiar presence that, for years, accompanied the simple act of opening the door.

Then comes the silence.

Losing a dog or a cat can make familiar places feel unexpectedly strange. Everything is where it has always been, yet something has changed in every corner.

And while we try to find our way through this absence, a thought may surface: “I shouldn’t be this upset.”

This is one of the difficulties of grieving a pet: finding ourselves judging our pain at the very moment we need room to feel it.

The place they held in our lives

A bond develops through seemingly small things.

The ways we seek each other out. The rhythms that become routines. Learning to recognise a need from a movement. That particular kind of companionship in which being together does not require finding something to say.

Gradually, a presence becomes woven into our days and our sense of being at home.

When they die, we also lose a shared everyday life. There are gestures with nowhere to go, acts of care that still reach towards the one who received them.

Perhaps some of the disorientation begins here: the relationship held a very real place in our lives, while the world around us seems to expect that place to become available again quite quickly.

“You can get another one.”

But the one we miss belongs to a particular history. Having someone else occupy the same corner of the sofa cannot recreate it.

When grief is accompanied by shame

Research on pet bereavement frequently describes a lack of social recognition: people who are grieving may feel misunderstood, embarrassed or alone. This is often referred to as disenfranchised grief—grief that is not fully acknowledged or supported by others. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Sometimes we begin to see ourselves through that same dismissive lens.

We compare our loss with others we consider more serious. We tell ourselves to be reasonable. We stop talking about it because we feel we have already taken up enough space.

Alongside the absence, we then have to manage the fear that missing them so much says something troubling about us.

In my approach to psychotherapy, understanding grief means exploring the relationship in which it has its roots. What did that presence mean? What aspects of our life did it hold together?

The question “Should I really feel this bad?” can gradually make room for another: “What else have I lost in losing them?”

How long does pet grief last?

It is understandable to want to know. When we are hurting, we want at least to glimpse an ending.

But grief does not follow a fixed sequence of stages. We may move between moments when the loss occupies almost everything and moments when we become absorbed in everyday life again. Stroebe and Schut’s dual process model describes this movement, including the need for respite from grief. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

You might laugh and immediately feel guilty. Or feel better for a few days, then assume you are back where you started because a photograph brings you to tears.

Perhaps we can resist turning grief into another test we have to pass.

Giving ourselves time means allowing the loss to be present in different ways. Sometimes through talking. Sometimes through keeping a familiar object. At other times through going out, working or thinking about something else.

If the distress feels unmanageable or makes everyday life very difficult, seeking support can offer a space where you do not have to face it all alone.

When feeling better seems like a betrayal

A quieter question can accompany grief: if I stop hurting this much, what will be left of us?

As though pain has become the last place where the bond still feels alive. And allowing it to change would mean losing them again.

Perhaps this is where we need particular gentleness.

A relationship leaves traces beyond the pain of its ending: in memories, in habits, in the tenderness we discovered we were capable of. In the ways that knowing them changed us.

We do not have to decide immediately what to do with all of this.

There may come a day when we describe one of their little habits and find ourselves smiling before we cry. The absence is still there, but alongside it there is room for something of the life we shared.

That life deserves to be remembered for what it was.

And for more than how much it hurt to lose it.

Further reading

Romina Rubino — Psychotherapist and Relational Psychoanalyst
Psychotherapy in English and Italian, in North London and online.

You might also like